Gluten Free Ice Cream Sandwiches (with Molasses Cookies)

**Please be sure to sign up for the Virtual GF BBQ Party!**
(See this post for more information)

Okay, now I know you think I’m absolutely nuts. I’m complaining about how cold it is around here (63F, hello? It’s JUNE!) and now I’m posting about ice cream sandwiches. Really… I know the end of the year is taking a toll on me, but it’s not that bad. I promise.

A little over a week ago, it was warm and toasty here. And yesterday, as I sat shivering and watching the late news (under a comforter, mind you), I saw that my family in Chicago had 91F yesterday. HOLY CATS! I bet they wish the same thing I did – that they could send me at least SOME of that! I wouldn’t mind.

Needless to say, my ice cream sandwich making was inspired not necessarily by the weather but by Tovolo. I found a set of Tovolo Ice Cream Sandwich Molds that I watched and coveted. But I have made ice cream sandwiches before with just cookie cutters. I couldn’t figure out why I would want an “ice cream sandwich molds“. Well, lemme tell ya, I know now!

And I’m not turning back. No way.

The Tovolo molds have three parts and work not only as a mold, but also as a cookie cutter. The first thing you do is bake your cookies as a thin pan cookie (or however thick you want them). Then you separate (easy, peasy…like Tupperware) the bottom/base and the press from the mold. You use it like a cookie cutter to cut two (a top and a bottom) from the pan cookies. Then you put the base back on, scoop in a scoop (or scoop and a half ) of ice cream, place another cut cookie shape on top and press together with the press that is part of the Tovolo mold. (Here’s a four part picture of the process AFTER cutting the cookies.)

Here’s a close up of the heart-shaped mold I used.

The Tovolo molds saved me a HUGE amount of time and mess. When I used the cookie cutters, I was cutting through ice cream to shape it to the sandwich. With the molds, I just press and go. It’s so easy.

I bought the traditional shaped Tovolo molds. You know, for the “public” ice cream sandwiches.

And… um… I’m coveting the Tovolo Farmyard Ice Cream Sandwich Molds. Come on! A chicken head ? A cow’s head? A pig’s head? Who could resist! Seriously…. they have officially been added to my Amazon Wish List. 😀 If it makes you laugh? Well, then…it’s irresistible.

For these Ice Cream Sandwiches, I made Molasses Cookies. I made a large recipe (which made a 14+sandwiches with lots of edges/leftovers for a pie crust later). I imagine this recipe would make 3 dozen cookies if I made them into regular cookies.

I hope you get a chance to enjoy a tasty ice cream sandwich. There are so many, many ways to vary them and keep them fresh and fun. Changing the ice cream or sorbet or sherbet….. Using different cookies (lemon? vanilla? pecan?) and rolling the edges in your favorite toppings (mini-chocolate chips? , nuts? berries?).

Wrap your sandwiches in plastic wrap individually and freeze all together in a large Ziploc or airtight container. (I left mine out a tad longer than I would have normally because I was playing photographer. LOL)

I’d love to hear your favorite ice cream sandwich combinations. What would you make your chicken-headed ice cream sandwich taste like? Or are you more about the stars, hearts, and squares? Whichever you chose, please feel free to try it with these Molasses cookies. They are a tasty addition to my usually chocolate ones.

Gluten Free Molasses Cookies/Bars
Makes 3 dozen cookies or 14 ice cream sandwiches

1 cup sorghum or rice flour
1 cup potato starch (NOT flour)
2/3 cup tapioca starch
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 Tablespoon baking powder
1/2 Tablespoon (1 1/2 teaspoons) cinnamon
1 teaspoon ground cloves
1 teaspoon ground ginger
1 cup butter, softened
1 1/2 cups brown sugar
1/3 cup molasses
2 eggs


  1. Preheat oven to 350F
  2. Cream together butter and brown sugar until light and fluffy.
  3. Add molasses and eggs. Beat together for 2-3 minutes.
  4. Whisk together dry ingredients (flour through ground ginger).
  5. Add to wet ingredients and beat to combine.
  6. TO MAKE COOKIES: Spoon onto parchment paper or silpat baking sheet (2 tablespoons = 1 cookie, approximately). Bake for 11-13 minutes or until the edges begin to crisp.
  7. TO MAKE ICE CREAM SANDWICHES: Line a large pan (I use an 18 by 24 inch jelly roll pan) with parchment paper. Use a wet rubber spatula to smooth out the cookie dough to be evenly thin on the pan. Bake for 25-30 minutes or until the center is cooked through and the edges are slightly crispy. Let cool for 2-3 minutes and then cut into the desired shapes for ice cream sandwiches. To make the sandwiches, either follow the Tovolo directions (as outlined above) or these.

Happy SUMMER Weather (for those of you who have it!) & Ice Cream Sandwiches for ALL!


  1. Oh man, now you’ve gone and done it! Those look fantastic!

  2. I can’t stop clicking back here and drooling over these… they look SO GOOD!!

  3. Those are SO super cute! and the cookies look delicious too!

  4. Kristina says:

    Too fun! I have an amazon gift card…may have to invest in these! I love the idea of molasses cookies- I’m thinking with some vanilla ice cream, rolled in chopped crystallized ginger. Thanks for the inspiration!

  5. oh my god those look so good. I can’t wait to spend the summer making ice cream sandwich cookies, once I dig my trusty ice cream maker out of the closet!!

  6. I think I have a couple of older, deep cookie cutters that would do the same thing pretty well. It seems to me I’ve seen a similar mold somewhere lately. I definitely need to try the technique at least. With the price of Rice based ice cream, though, I might need to make mini sandwiches!!

    The cookie cutters will work too, Zebe and I’ve used them before as well. Since the mold has a top/bottom, it makes it MUCH easier to press together and NOT have to cut the ice cream to fit the shape of the cookie….. thus my new found love of Tovolo. LOL – Kate

  7. these look great! I can’t wait to try them.

    I just found your blog today. Its great!

    I am hosting a gluten free products giveaway at my blog. Please join if you’d like!

  8. Oh yum, tasty and adorable too! (Not that I’ve eaten them, but I can just tell they taste good!)


  9. can’t wait to try the ice cream sandwiches—-or maybe i’ll just make the recipe as cookies. great site—-i’ve added you to my google reader. please visit my sites and


  10. madcapCupcake says:

    These simply look AWESOME. I must make this for my GF sister…and while I’m at it, eat about ten myself 🙂

  11. These did not turn out for me at all- the cookies flattened so much that they turned into one big cookie- a very thin cookie. they tasted great, but there was so much waste as i tried to get them out in something resembling pieces/cookies.

    i think we’re going to toss the crumbs w/ some ice cream to avoid waste. 😛

    i wonder why they did not form up as cookies?

  12. This did not work out for me as cookies, either. It all ran together into one big blob~ I wonder what could be done to make them stick together better??

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: